Grilled Beef Heart Steaks with Spicy Lime Marinade - Rebel Pastures

Grilled Beef Heart Steaks with Spicy Lime Marinade

Justin loves steak. So when people kept telling him beef heart tastes like lean steak with far more nutrition, he wanted to see for himself.

In the video below, Jenni and Justin walk you through every step: trimming a whole heart, mellowing it in a milk soak, marinating it in a bright lime and aji panca blend, and grilling it to medium-rare. If you've been curious about organ meats but haven't found a way you enjoy them, start here.

And don't worry—the marinade doesn't pack a lot of heat. The aji panca  or chili powder in the marinade just add a nice, spiced flavor.

No beef heart? Use your favorite steak. This exact recipe works with any of our steak cuts, including our sizzler steak and sirloin steak. Same marinade, same grill method, same pull temps. Steak carries a little more fat than heart, so it's more forgiving on the grill.

Meet the heart

A typical beef heart weighs 3 to 5 pounds. The ones we sell are half of a heart, which gives you a sense of the size you're working with.

Heart is a muscle, so it cooks and eats more like steak than other organ meats. It's dense, lean, and mild, with none of the strong mineral flavor people associate with liver.

Why beef heart belongs on your plate

Beef heart is one of the most nutrient-dense cuts on the whole animal. Here's what a 3-ounce cooked serving delivers:

Nutrient

Per 3 oz cooked

% Daily Value

Vitamin B12

9.2 mcg

about 380%

Riboflavin (B2)

1 mg

about 80%

Selenium

33 mcg

about 60%

Copper

0.5 mg

about 55%

Iron (heme)

5.4 mg

about 30%

Protein

24 g

—

Source: NutritionValue, beef heart, cooked, simmered.

The iron in heart is heme iron, the form your body absorbs most readily. And at about 140 calories per serving, it's one of the leanest ways to get this much protein from beef.

Honoring the whole animal

Our partner farmers put months of time and care into raising every animal we sell. When an animal is processed, we want to use all of it. Cooking cuts like heart is part of showing these animals the respect they deserve, and it's one of the simplest ways to eat closer to the way your great-grandparents did.

Pasture raised, grilled beef heart steak strips sitting on a plate.

Recipe 

Grilled Beef Heart Steaks with Spicy Lime Marinade

Prep: 20 minutes · Soak: 20 minutes to overnight (optional) · Marinate: 1 hour to overnight · Grill: medium heat

Ingredients

For the heart

For the marinade

  • ½ cup fresh lime juice
  • 3-4 tablespoons aji panca paste or 2-3 teaspoons chili powder
  • 6 cloves garlic, minced
  • 1½ teaspoons salt
  • 1 teaspoon black pepper
  • 1 teaspoon ground cumin
  • 4 tablespoons extra virgin olive oil

Instructions

  1. Trim. Cut away the tough inner valves, stringy tendons, and blood vessel tubes. Trim off the outer fat deposits. Using steak? Just trim any large pieces of fat or gristle.
  2. Rinse and cube. Rinse the heart under cold water and cut it into 2-inch wide strips.
  3. Soak (optional). Cover the strips in milk and refrigerate for 20 minutes to overnight. This mellows the flavor. Drain before marinating. Skip this step for steak.
  4. Make the marinade. Whisk together the lime juice, aji panca paste or chili powder, garlic, salt, pepper, cumin, and olive oil.
  5. Marinate. Toss the strips in the marinade until fully coated. Refrigerate for at least 1 hour, or overnight for the most flavor.
  6. Grill. Heat the grill to medium. Apply olive oil to grill to avoid sticking. Place the strips away from hot spots and close the lid.
  7. Flip and check often. Every few minutes, open the lid, flip the strips, and check the internal temperature. Heart is very lean, so it cooks faster than steak.
  8. Pull at temp. Remove at 125°F for rare or 130–135°F for medium-rare. Overcooked heart turns tough and chewy.

Tips for first-timers

  • Use a thermometer. Heart goes from tender to tough in a matter of minutes. Don't cook by eye.
  • Don't skip the trim. The valves and tendons stay chewy no matter how you cook them. A sharp boning knife makes this quick.
  • Plan ahead. Both the soak and the marinade work best overnight. Prep the night before and dinner comes together fast.
  • Find aji panca in the international aisle of most grocery stores, at Latin markets, or online. It's a mild, smoky Peruvian chili paste. Chili powder is a convenient alternative.

Give it a try

Beef heart steaks are one of the easiest ways to add more nutrition to your table, honor the whole animal, and try a cut you may have never cooked before. Justin went in skeptical. He came out a convert. And if you'd rather start with a familiar cut, the same marinade turns beef kabobs, sizzler steak, or sirloin into a weeknight favorite.

Shop All Beef Cuts →

 

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.